Kookaburra Coffee Co

Nadia Benes 2 months ago

I got the Earl Grey Carrot Muffin and it was the best muffin I've ever had! Perfect crisp on the top and incredibly moist inside. The coffee was smooth and delicious as well!

Diana Brewster 5 months ago

Visit Date: April 28, 2026 I came to Kookaburra before my endocrinologist appointment. It was in my LI Cafe Passport book. I've noticed some reviews say they are cash only, I paid in cash but I also saw some customers using debit cards. I got my dad a bag of coffee because I have Christmas money I had saved to take him out and we only went to Panera a few times so I've been buying him bags of coffee from the nice coffee shops. I got an iced cafe mocha with half and half. It was very good, creamy, chocolately and it gave a nice buzzzz. The coffee shop itself is very small, most of the space is dedicated to their coffee machines and food service. There is limited seating outside but it's not a place where they encourage you to stay and hang out after you get your coffee. It's still good though. It's more of a grab and go coffee spot. They also have no bathrooms but if you ask for a bathroom they will refer you to the train station or the cathedral near the coffee shop. I would recommend coming here for coffee it's really good but if you're looking to linger you can't.

Ashwin Ragupathi 5 months ago

First and foremost, the coffee is genuinely outstanding across the board, but the real star of the show for me is their cold brew. It is incredibly smooth, perfectly balanced, and packs just the right amount of punch without any of that harsh, overly acidic bitterness you sometimes get at larger chain cafes. Whether I am grabbing it on a warm morning or just desperately needing a mid-day pick-me-up, their cold brew never fails to hit the exact right spot. It is refreshing, robust, and crafted with obvious care. Honestly, if I had to point out one single downside to this place, it would strictly be their operating hours. They close so early! I frequently find myself craving their amazing cold brew or wanting to drop by for an afternoon pick-me-up, only to realize they have already shut their doors for the day. I genuinely wish they stayed open just a little bit later into the afternoon because I simply can't get enough of it. Despite the early closing time, Kookaburra Coffee Co easily earns a flawless rating from me. Great prices, friendly faces, and hands down the best cold brew around. Highly recommended!

Zac Goldstein 11 months ago

(4.5 stars) Doesn’t take credit cards? No place to sit? Line out the door? Given the first two, I suspected that this place must be something special for the third to hold true. Thankfully, I was right. From coffees and teas to donuts and bagels and more, Kookaburra has an impressive selection. Whether you want a simple haht cawfee or something more extravagant, they have you covered. The baristas are amicable and adept at keeping the line moving. For our first visit, my wife and I ended up with a NOLA cold brew (with chicory), a toasted marshmallow caramel latte, and a maple Berliner to share. Everything was good, and honestly not that expensive by New York standards. The coffee was smooth and not too sweet while the donut tasted fresh. Impressed, I returned the next day to snag a graham cracker latte and an Irish cream cold brew. The second round of Kookaburra drinks was just as satisfying as the first. If you’re in a hurry or really want to be able to sit inside and eat/drink, you can try the Dunkin down the street. If you don’t mind waiting a few minutes, paying cash, and taking your coffee to go, then Kookaburra offers an experience that is hard to beat.

Akila Iyer 2 years ago

JUST OKAY! I requested a decaf coffee with cream. The lady helping me poured milk into the coffee cup. They don’t keep any sugar or supplies outside. I asked for 1 packet of stevia and found that it wasn’t sufficient for me. It would be great if they keep the creamer, sugar and supplies outside so that customers can use them accordingly. The coffee was bitter and tasted just OK.